trophy
| 1995-1996 | 1996-1997 | 1997-1998 | 1998-1999 | 1999-2000 |
| Molson's Red Dog | Rickerd's Red | Miller Draft | Canadians | Karlee's Leafs |
| Ken Cillis | Ken MacLeod | Ian Hunter | Brian Deans | Brian Perotti |
| William Andrews | Doug Russel | Dave Keller | Gord MacLean | P. Shewchuk |
| George Baichiu | Rick Sabourin | Will Kunder | Terry Gudgeon | J. Janczak |
| Ben DeRubeis | John McMurty | Ken Cillis | Roy Waldhuber | B. Bodden |
| Roger Herdon | Rick Smith | John Cosentino | Joe Cantwell | G. Kalles |
| Ian Hunter | Jim Albanese | Rick McFarlane | John Balsillie | G. King |
| Paul Miller | Bill Mighton | Doug Sabbe | Gord Johnson | P. Miller |
| Dan Pergentile | Jim Laidman | Frank Sergi | Jerry Nardone | Frank Sergi |
| William Reid | Jim Downey | Rich Smith | Tom Wighton | R. Smith |
| Wayne Pride | Stan Simpson | Jack Wood | Len Wise | M. Shewchuk |
| Rick Smith | Brian Jones | Dennis Castellani | George Kalles | Roy Waldhuber |
| Rob Waldhuber | Wayne Lanagan | Wayne Delorey | Brian Rode | L. Blobrk |
| Mike Walker | Roy Cabral | Joe Tittarelli | Dominic Rosati | J. Ellis |
| Bill Hamilton | Ron Payne | Richard Wilson | Rick Smith | D. Gabriele |
| - | - | - | - | B. Mighton |
